By: T F Stern – T F Stern’s Rantings
My goodness; but my last article, Mother Earth Rights – A Rose by Any Other Name, set off a firestorm of controversy. My Facebook account went off like a Roman Candle trying to “set me straight” for having expressed my summation of historical facts. Here’s what got some folks upset, enough to waggle a finger in my direction:
“America was founded upon Christian values. Our sacred documents include the Scriptures, Declaration of Independence, the Constitution and Bill of Rights. Individual rights are gifts from our Creator, not something Congress came up with. Our Constitution and Bill of Rights were put in place to protect individual God-given rights FROM Congress and the natural expansion of government powers. America only works if a majority of its inhabitants voluntarily uphold the principles of self-governance as set forth in these sacred documents.”
The first comment pointed me toward a treaty signed long ago. It read in part, “…treaty of tripoli submitted to the Senate by President John Adams, receiving ratification unanimously from the U.S. Senate on June 7, 1797 and signed by Adams, taking effect as the law of the land on June 10, 1797 states, “As the Government of the United States of America is not, in any sense, founded on the Christian religion….”
All I could remember about that time period and geography had to do with pirates taking advantage of ships at sea and how America took care of the problem by creating the U.S. Navy to protect vessels traveling in those waters.
I looked up the Treaty of Tripoli to get a better understanding of it. Sure enough, there is a statement expressing one of America’s first “Politically Correct” positions; should we be surprised, it was written by a career diplomat, Joel Barlow.
“Art. 11. As the Government of the United States of America is not, in any sense, founded on the Christian religion; as it has in itself no character of enmity against the laws, religion, or tranquillity, of Mussulmen; and, as the said States never entered into any war, or act of hostility against any Mahometan nation, it is declared by the parties, that no pretext arising from religious opinions, shall ever produce an interruption of the harmony existing between the two countries.” (spelling and grammar unchanged)
I thought it odd, at least momentarily, an obscure document of limited historical value would surface with precisely the perfect line required to counter my statement, “America was founded upon Christian values,” much less, within minutes of the article being posted. I don’t believe in “coincidence,” but this particular line appeared to give credence to the gauntlet thrown down. Had I been mistaken and was this the golden bullet to shoot me down?
My guess, based on having dealt with several highly educated “non-believers” on other topics; this was the “go to” answer; one which had been researched and saved by like minded non-believers over the years. A means to defeat anyone claiming the United States was founded on Christian principles. The fact that such a thought passed my consciousness led me to conclude my suspicions were spot on.
Students are routinely challenged to defend certain positions, theories and opinions; especially in public schools or places of higher education when the topic of religion comes up. If confronted with this “go to” answer an unsteadied person might throw in the towel and quietly admit defeat; such is not the case as will be unfolded below.
There were several articles under the heading “Treaty of Tripoli,” which shed light on the dangers involved with ships on the high seas and negotiations with Muslim nations involved openly in piracy. The most informative piece by David Barton included a considerable number of historical facts excluded in other reports which discounted the importance of Article 11.
“It would also be absurd to suggest that President Adams (under whom the treaty was ratified in 1797) would have endorsed or assented to any provision which repudiated Christianity. In fact, while discussing the Barbary conflict with Jefferson, Adams declared:
The policy of Christendom has made cowards of all their sailors before the standard of Mahomet. It would be heroical and glorious in us to restore courage to ours.
Furthermore, it was Adams who declared:
The general principles on which the fathers achieved independence were. . . . the general principles of Christianity. . . . I will avow that I then believed, and now believe, that those general principles of Christianity are as eternal and immutable as the existence and attributes of God; and that those principles of liberty are as unalterable as human nature.
Adams’ own words confirm he rejected any notion that America was less than a Christian nation.”
President Adams was not bashful in proclaiming America to be a Christian nation; but since Adams signed* the “politically correct” document, a document intended to mollify several hundred years of hatred between European nations of dubious Christian adherence with Muslim nation states harboring blood thirsty pirates; well, you don’t have to be a rocket scientist to read between the lines and figure out the purpose for Article 11.
Another comment pointed the way to the Avalon Project which contradicted the authenticity of Barlow’s translation of the Treaty of Tripoli, the version used by non-believers to discount American links to Christianity. According to the document on file in the National Archives there is no reference to an Article 11.
“As even a casual examination of the annotated translation of 1930 shows, the Barlow translation is at best a poor attempt at a paraphrase or summary of the sense of the Arabic; and even as such its defects throughout are obvious and glaring. Most extraordinary (and wholly unexplained) is the fact that Article 11 of the Barlow translation, with its famous phrase, “the government of the United States of America is not in any sense founded on the Christian Religion,” *does not exist at all. There is no Article 11. The Arabic text which is between Articles 10 and 12 is in form a letter, crude and flamboyant and withal quite unimportant, from the Dey of Algiers to the Pasha of Tripoli. How that script came to be written and to be regarded, as in the Barlow translation, as Article 11 of the treaty as there written, is a mystery and seemingly must remain so. Nothing in the diplomatic correspondence of the time throws any light whatever on the point.”
It would seem history has been “toyed with;” a generous way of saying somebody wished to create a slippery slope of doubt regarding America having been established on Christian principles.
While looking for enlightenment, either for or against the idea that “America was founded upon Christian values,” it was remarkable how many negative articles Google had listed. A goodly portion of articles espoused excessive loathing for anything religious or conservative in nature; but having used Google for other searches, the top listed results didn’t surprise me, a telling statement on priorities.
The idea occurred, much as in the movie, Miracle on 34th Street, each side could parade an endless supply of factoids to defend or attack the statement. Were there any historically undeniable facts which could be counted on to settle once and for all my claim, “America was founded upon Christian values?” The answer came out, probably not.
Those who refuse to believe the Scriptures have the same reaction to historically recorded facts if recorded by one with an opposing mindset. It wouldn’t matter if I had John Adams on digital recording, boldly proclaiming America as the Lord’s chosen nation. No, it wouldn’t sway my detractors one iota. Fat chance of finding such a recording since it had not been invented at the time. No employee of the U.S. Postal Service was going to haul sacks filled with date stamped testimonies from each of our founders.
One of the books in my personal library came to mind as I read the various challenges to America having been founded on Christian principles, The Christian Life and Character of the Civil Institutions of the United States, by Benjamin F. Morris. It had been a while so I dusted it off and speed read a few chapters from the beginning. (Below is a scanned image of page 46, please click on it to enlarge.)
Quoting from state papers of the Continental Congress, predecessor to our Constitutional Republic, try this statement on for size.
“…that the nation may be made a holy nation, and that the religion of our divine Redeemer, with all its benign influences, may cover the earth as the waters do the sea:”
Maybe it’s just me; but it would seem to go far beyond “implying” America was founded upon Christian doctrine. Remember; this is part of our nation’s official record.
As you glance over this one page, be aware, the book contains 1060 pages with similar historically accurate accounts which could only be understood to mean exactly what my short opening summary recorded, “America was founded upon Christian values.”
This article has been cross-posted to The Moral Liberal, a publication whose banner reads, “Defending The Judeo-Christian Ethic, Limited Government & The American Constitution.”
6 thoughts on “We Started Out a Christian Nation”
Exceptional blog post!!!
I dont disagree with this post!
Founding a country, and guiding its founding on a certain subset of values and principles believed to be just and right does not in any way wholly and inextricably bind that country to the religion from which those values were obtained.
The …words of the Declaration of Independence were all chosen extremely carefully. The word “Creator” was not an accident; it refers to the rights of each individual to acknowledge their own believed creator in the manner they see fit.
The US Constitution, with its words chosen with at least as much care as the declaration (but likely a hell of a lot more considering it was to act as the basis of the new country’s government) does not reference God or any supreme being whatsoever. That was also not an accident. The Bill of Rights goes even further, specifically separating government and religion right in the first amendment.
Regarding the 1st Amendment, Thomas Jefferson referred to it as a “wall of separation between church and state”. James Madison is also quoted as saying “Strongly guarded… is the separation between religion and government in the Constitution of the United States.” The motives during the founding of the United States are clear.
And then there’s the aforementioned Treaty of Tripoli which, unanimously approved by the Senate, plainly states that the United States is not a Christian nation.
So while Christianity may have been an influence in the values and principles which guided the founding of this country, it was not founded as a Christian nation.
Influence and doctrine are two hugely different things.
I have to agree with you, the points you cover are exactly what was done then. The simple fact is our country is established by the ideals of Christianity, for indeed our rights and liberties do come from the Creator; the sets of morals, of rights, of conscience and of free will and free choice to follow the right or the wrong path in life we all share equally, just as each one of us will stand to accounting of it in the end individually, yet by the same set of universal standards.
As it states in the old testament, God in not a resperctor of the person. We are all held to the standards of Him and Jesus, as shown in the bible.
Good essay on our Christian origins. What few realize is there are two “United States of Americas”, one on the State level, and the other on the “federal” or “national” level. The two are opposites.
The “America” our Founders erected existed on the State level. The citizens were only found in and among the States. Only the State governments administered the Biblical common-law of liberty protecting our God given unalienable “natural” rights. Every State Constitution had a Bill of Rights in it. Every State Constitution begins by recognizing God as the source of our liberty.
The “national” government was created by the States to serve them in international law capacity. It was vested with a military international law authority which does not recognize and protect rights; it enforces (contract) law.
This international law (admiralty jurisdiction) is the same “alien jurisdiction” complained of in the Declaration of Independence which provoked the Revolutionary War. As admiralty is incompatible with liberty, a “wall of separation” was erected between the States and the national governments.
The “federal” government does not recognize God, natural law (common-law), or our unalienable “natural” rights. It only recognizes and enforces statutes (positive law).
After the Civil War, the Civil Rights Act of 1866 and the 14th Amendment established a “federal” citizenship for the freed slaves as they could not be admitted to citizenship in any of the States. The Civil Rights Acts “grant” to minorities statutory “civil rights” and “statutory equality” with the founding generation (State citizens), who did not need statutes to provide them with rights, theirs came from God and pre-dated government . “Civil rights” come from Congress, not God. “Federal” America was not created by our Founding Fathers, but by self serving carpetbagger politicians.
A UNANOMOUS Sup. Ct. decision in Trinity vs. US, after 10 yrs. of researching every one of our founding documents, declared us to be a religious people, a CHRISTIAN NATION.
Nine of the original Thirteen States had “establishment” clauses in their Constitution declaring the (Christian) Protestant religion the “established” religion in that State.
The infamous Treaty of Tripoli is not one of our founding documents. It was entered into under duress because Tripoli was giving sanctuary to the Barbary Pirates who were holding our merchant vessels, cargo, and crews for ransom. Tripoli was a muslim nation forbidden to negotiate with Christians.
Four yrs. after this Treaty, the Bey of Tripoli dishonored it and a new one was written, this time beginning like every other Treaty this country entered into: “In the name of the Holy Blessed Trinity…”
It may be argued that the government of “The United States” (the title of the “federal” government) was not founded upon Christian principles, but it was created by Christian State governments, who were. These were the individual, autonomous, sovereign States united in a Union under the Constitution – The United “States” of America.